A Place to MeetWood-fired pizzeria, coffee, wine & cocktail bar, gelato, & take out

Celebrating 26 Years!
dal 2000

Walk-ins welcome in our dining room, patio and bar. Parties of 6 to 12 can reserve on Resy. For larger parties or seating questions, call a host at 920-803-7516. Event requests go to events@stefanosrestaurantgroup.com.

Pizzaiolo working at Il Ritrovo's tiled wood-fired pizza oven beside the Vera Pizza Napoletana sign

About Us

Our wood fire pizza oven has been burning here in Sheboygan since 2000 when Il Ritrovo became the 5th Certified Vera Pizza Napoletana member in the United States. We use slow-fermented dough, fresh mozzarella made from Wisconsin curd daily, air-shipped Bufala mozzarella, and San Marzano tomatoes kissed by the sun and the sea at the base of Mount Vesuvius.  We strive to balance seasonal and sustainable ingredients with Italian methods to achieve the essence of Neapolitan pizza.

VPN & APN Certified

Pizzeria in Sheboygan, Wisconsin

Baked pasta topped with grated cheese in a terra cotta dish

Our Restaurants & Market

Stefano's Slo Food Market Field to Fork Cafe and Grocery Trattoria Stefano

What People Are Saying

The Best!

“My son and I had two pizzas here Friday night and they were the best pizzas we have ever eaten. We go out of our way to taste good pizzas and have been to New York, L.A., Miami, and Chicago tasting their best pies. We never expected to find this quality in Sheboygan but it's world class and every time we attend races at Road America we will look forward to our next pizzas here.”

Vera Pizza Napoletana certification logo

Vera Pizza Napoletana certified

“Anyone who doubts the pizza chops of the Midwest beyond Chicago has never been to Sheboygan. This town of 50,000 people just north of Milwaukee has two AVPN-certified pizzerias. Il Ritrovo, in the heart of town off Pennsylvania Avenue, is a Wisconsin experience as memorable as a dog and brew at Miller Park.

Substitute the dog for pizza and the brew for a bottle of wine, of course. The pies are as classy as the setting, and the specialità della casa is known as the Margherita Maxi e Bufala. The restaurant has an on-site deli and market, so you can take a bit of the goodness with you when you leave.”

Source:
https://matadornetwork.com/read/certified-neapolitan-pizzerias-us/